Refuting a warn.


Kenny McCormick  VIP 23 Sep 20 at 3:25pm
#11
(23 Sep 20 at 3:23pm)[DEFN] Combine Elite ( Umbra ) Wrote: Ive also been warned for this exact same reason. You cant base off sound, You gotta see it for it to be true. For mace and SU its different though

Basing off sound for anarchists is different than basing off guns. If you hear a sword gunning down F stairs then of course youd be able to know an enemy is down there. But anarchists got some shitty metagame rules I believe

Guns and knives make distinct sounds, and are part of distinct classes, which is why he killed the Civ because he heard a knife which is used ONLY by anarchs outside of events.

Signature:
love me some lore
former hgm, npu dvl (sentry), lvet co
[DEFN] Combine Elite ( Umbra )  VIP 23 Sep 20 at 3:27pm
#12
(23 Sep 20 at 3:25pm)kcimroCcM ynneK Wrote:
(23 Sep 20 at 3:23pm)[DEFN] Combine Elite ( Umbra ) Wrote: Ive also been warned for this exact same reason. You cant base off sound, You gotta see it for it to be true. For mace and SU its different though

Basing off sound for anarchists is different than basing off guns. If you hear a sword gunning down F stairs then of course youd be able to know an enemy is down there. But anarchists got some shitty metagame rules I believe

Guns and knives make distinct sounds, and are part of distinct classes, which is why he killed the Civ because he heard a knife which is used ONLY by anarchs outside of events.

As I said. I still stand by my Neutral post as I do believe he did a wrong by killing the Civilian.
Serry  VIP 23 Sep 20 at 3:56pm Edited
#13
So the sound of pulling out a knife and reacting to it is metagame?

We have to go deaf now so we dont react to obvious threats or else it will be a warn
Free the man of the warn

Signature:
Gamer
Bel1ve.  VIP 23 Sep 20 at 4:16pm
#14
-1
Could have been someone else, Sure you may have only seen him there but there could be someone around you
have not spotted therefor you could have shot down an innocent civilian.
mantis  VIP 23 Sep 20 at 4:39pm
#15
(23 Sep 20 at 4:16pm)Bel1ve. Wrote: -1
Could have been someone else, Sure you may have only seen him there but there could be someone around you
have not spotted therefor you could have shot down an innocent civilian.

After I killed him all I saw was how empty the field was, like I said it was only me and him, the server was pretty dead by then so I can say that it was pretty much empty.

Signature:
OVA SWAT OFC-II Mantis
[Image: caption.gif]
Bel1ve.  VIP 23 Sep 20 at 5:01pm Edited
#16
(23 Sep 20 at 4:39pm)mantis Wrote:
(23 Sep 20 at 4:16pm)Bel1ve. Wrote: -1
Could have been someone else, Sure you may have only seen him there but there could be someone around you
have not spotted therefor you could have shot down an innocent civilian.

After I killed him all I saw was how empty the field was, like I said it was only me and him, the server was pretty dead by then so I can say that it was pretty much empty.


From my painful 17 warns I learned that presuming is not allowed and would get you straight up warned.
Unless they decided to change the rules again, for now I'll stick with my statement until it's stated by HA that its allowed.
Dodgy  VIP 23 Sep 20 at 6:02pm
#17
Accepted

Given that no one else was in the vicinity other than the civilian, the knife sound was proper justification to take action against the civilian. User's warn will be removed.
  • 9 participants


  • Forum Jump